...

Lead Generation for Lawyers: Best Practices for Conversion

by Fadi Agour | Mar 18, 2019

Lead management best practices to successfully convert leads

Here is our list of six lead management best practices to help your firm sign up more clients.

1. Use a virtual receptionist so no call goes unanswered

A study on law firm client intake showed that on average, 35% of calls from prospective clients go unanswered. You shouldn’t assume these people will wait around and try calling you back later. When they can’t reach you, they probably just move on to the next firm.

You may not be able to pay a full time receptionist to answer every single call for you, and that is completely understandable. But neglecting 35% of your potential clients will surely hamper your efforts to grow your practice.

That’s why one of our lead management best practices is to use a 24/7 virtual receptionist service. When no call goes unanswered, you will show your prospects that you are always available, build their trust, and maximize the likelihood of a lead converting into a paying client.

2. Urgency: Respond to every lead within 15 minutes

Studies have shown that lead response time is a key factor in whether or not a sale closes – the faster the response time, the better the conversion rate. Not only that, but the first responder to a lead is also far more likely to win the person’s business.

Lawyers face a lot of competition in the market these days. You should not assume that potential clients who contact you will not also contact another attorney. And you should do everything in your power to have someone call every single lead within the first 15 minutes.

Responsiveness is a key indicator to a client that you care about them and this will help you establish their trust, and maximize the likelihood of a conversion.

3. Persistence: Make a minimum of 3-5 attempts to contact every lead everyday

Time and time again, studies have shown that persistence pays when it comes to sales. There are a million reasons why a prospect may not reply when you first contact them. But you should never just assume it’s a lost cause.

You should contact every prospect at least 3-5 times, or until you hear back from them. You should try multiple contact methods as well, including both phone, email, and SMS messaging.

The more follow up attempts you make, the more likely you will be to get through, and the more likely that the person will hire you. It’s that simple.

4. If you don’t receive a response after 3-5 attempts, use email marketing to keep leads engaged

Even after 3-5 failed attempts to contact a lead, you still shouldn’t give up hope completely. You just never know when the person might change their mind and reach back out to you, ready to hire.

It’s all about timing. You want to ensure that you stay top of mind so that your previous potential clients don’t go looking for another attorney when the timing is right.

The best way to keep nurturing these types of leads and maintain some level of engagement with them is to use email marketing. You can send out newsletters with general updates from your firm, or better yet, send along some FAQs, articles, or blog posts that are relevant to the person’s legal matter.

The more targeted these types of communications are, the more effective they will be at converting a cold lead into a hot one.

5. Pre-qualify your engaged leads with a simple online intake form

Depending on your area of practice, it often doesn’t make sense to schedule every single potential client for a consultation right away because you may just end up wasting your valuable time meeting with the wrong clients.

So, once you do have an engaged prospect, the next step is to pre-qualify them to ensure that they are a good fit for your firm and that you can help them with their legal needs.

A great way to pre-qualify your leads is to use a simple online intake form to capture some basic information before you meet with them. You can explain to your clients that filling out this short form is the first step of the process, and that it will help you assess their legal needs so you can properly advise them.

Using an online intake form will not only allow you to screen out bad clients, but also save you a bunch of time during the consultation because you’ll already have a better idea about the important issues which need to be discussed.

Since the form is fillable online, it’s much less of a burden on your clients than printing a form to fill out by hand would be.

6. Track all of your efforts in a CRM so nothing slips through the cracks

According to a study, 26% of law firms do not track their leads at all. Not in a spreadsheet. Not even on a notebook or a Post-it note.

Lead management is virtually impossible without a system for tracking your activities. For example, how will you know if you’ve made your 3-5 attempts to reach a lead if you don’t keep track of it somewhere? That’s what a CRM will do for you.

A CRM functions as your lead management database. It’s where you store each lead, including their contact info, their upcoming appointments, notes about interactions with them, emails you have sent them, and any tasks or reminders you set for you or your staff.

If you use a law firm specific CRM, you can even do things like trigger automatic email follow ups or appointment reminders, send online intake forms to complete, or send out an e-signable fee agreement. Many CRM tools enable you to monitor the current status of every single potential client.

By using a legal CRM tool, you’ll know which leads you haven’t been able to reach yet, which leads you have made contact with, which leads have a consultation scheduled, which leads had a consultation but have not hired you yet, etc.

Summary

As you should now see, lead management is fundamentally different from case management, but equally, if not more important to growing your firm. Paying for marketing without proper lead management is basically just throwing away your hard earned money.

In order to yield a positive ROI from marketing, you’ve got to have a system for managing, and converting your leads. By utilizing our six lead management best practices for law firms, you will be ahead of the curve when it comes to landing more business for your practice.

Explore More Articles

Why Law Firms Lose the Cases They Already Paid For: 6 Foundation Gaps We See From the Other Side

Marketing agencies write about law firm growth from the outside looking in. We have a different vantage point. Best Case Leads delivers exclusive personal injury leads to law firms across the country, which means we watch the same product, a real injured claimant...

Bicycle Crash Claims: What Personal Injury Firms Need to Know About Liability, Evidence, and Intake

In 2024, 1,103 cyclists were killed and an estimated 52,887 were injured in U.S. traffic crashes, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. For plaintiff firms, those crashes produce some of the most serious injuries in the motor vehicle docket...

The Jealous Mistress Was Always a Bad Business Model: A Growth Framework for Solo and Small Personal Injury Firms

The Jealous Mistress Was Always a Bad Business Model: A Growth Framework for Solo and Small Personal Injury Firms Justice Story's line about the law demanding "lavish homage" has been quoted to every law student for two centuries. It produced a profession with...

Nearly Half of Law Firms Cannot Be Reached by Phone. The Problem Is Not Marketing. It Is the Empty Chair Next to the Owner.

In 2024, Clio commissioned a secret-shopper study of American law firms. Researchers posed as prospective clients and contacted 500 firms by phone and email. The results, published in the 2024 Legal Trends Report, were unambiguous. Only 40 percent of firms answered...

The Trial Lawyer Who Never Tries a Case: How to Grow a Personal Injury Firm Without Losing the Only Leverage That Matters

In 1990, federal district courts completed 4,765 civil jury trials. In 2025, according to the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, they completed 1,048, a decline of 10 percent in a single year and roughly 78 percent over the generation. The state courts, where...

Best Case Leads Celebrates Sixth Consecutive Year on Inc. 5000 List of Fastest-Growing Private Companies in America

Aug 19, 2025 | Press Releases Houston, TX, August 18, 2025 — Best Case Leads, a pioneering leader in legal lead generation, proudly announces its sixth consecutive recognition on the prestigious Inc. 5000 fastest-growing private companies in America, securing...

Baby Formula Litigation, NEC Claims, and the Evolving Landscape of Mass Torts

By Fadi Agour, J.D. Families of premature infants who developed necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC) after being fed cow–milk–based formula products like Similac and Enfamil continue to pursue justice in both state and federal courts. Recent...

Mass Tort Landscape 2025: Key Cases, Trends & Strategic Opportunities

The mass tort landscape is evolving rapidly, with new cases gaining momentum and established litigations reaching critical phases. For law firms and legal marketers, timing is everything—success hinges on anticipating trends, securing high-value claimants early, and...

Zyprexa & Risperdal 2: The Breast Cancer Link That Could Ignite the Next Mass Tort

The pharmaceutical litigation landscape has seen its share of blockbuster cases—from opioid multidistrict litigations to the ongoing Paraquat Parkinson’s claims. But a new California lawsuit (Brown v. Johnson & Johnson et al.) could revive two legacy antipsychotics...

Mass Torts in 2025: A Legal Landscape in Flux

As 2025 unfolds, the world of mass tort litigation shows no signs of slowing down. From pharmaceutical giants to tech behemoths, corporations across industries are facing an unprecedented wave of lawsuits that could reshape their futures. With judges issuing critical...