...

The Best Time to Make a Follow-Up Call on Leads

by Fadi Agour | Apr 25, 2019

follow-up call

Did you know that the magic number for lead a lead follow-up is within the first five minutes from when they first contact you? Statistics show that you’re 100 times more likely to reach a prospect if you call them shortly after initial contact. This information alone is the link between success and falling flat on your face.

When to Make a Follow-Up Call

Remember, timing is everything, and the same goes when your goal is to turn a potential client into a paying one. But when is the best time to follow up on leads? Finding the best time to make a follow-up call to your prospects would depend on the service they need and when they’re available to talk.

Below, I will talk about the best time to reach your leads by case type.

Social Security Benefits

Most people who are applying for Social Security are not working, so the best time to reach them is during midday hours. Avoid calling them during mealtimes or early in the morning.

Personal Injuries

Depending on the severity of the injuries, call times can vary. If the lead can go to work, then call somewhere after 8 p.m. and if there are severe injuries, then any time of the day will do.

Workers’ Comp

You can reach individuals who filed and Worker’s Compensation claim at any time of the day. Because most claim filers, tend to be younger than Social Security applicants, you can also reach out to them by email or text message.

Bankruptcy

These are the hardest leads to reach, because not only are they working, but many potential clients screen calls due to collection agents. So the best way to contact them is by email or text message.

Coming up with a Plan

Around 37 percent of law firms follow up with their leads within an hour of the first call. But with planning, your response time will be even faster; so your prospects will become clients.

Below, we are going to talk about some of the most effective strategies and ideas to help you reach out to your leads. Not only will you leave your competition in the dust, but it will make follow up calling a breeze.

Make Sure You Have Dedicated Phone Lines

Law firms have a receptionist who takes several calls throughout the day. Sometimes they may not get to your request if they’re on the phone or away from their desk. The solution is to invest in a dedicated phone line so that all prospects can get answers to their questions.

Work with an Answering Service

Potential clients can call at any time, even if your law firm is closed for the evening. An answering service can take calls after hours to assist leads, which then converts into new customers.

Manage Your Form Submissions

Making sure that you are contacting your leads from form submissions is as vital as returning calls. You should also have a back-up in place, as well as forwarding these leads to the right person.

Schedule Your Lead Follow-Up Calls

There is no guarantee you’ll reach your leads when you call them back. You can solve this problem, by scheduling any follow-up calls, so candidates can see your dedication in helping them with their situation.

Conclusion

Finding the right time to make a follow-up call to each lead, can be frustrating, especially if you don’t have a plan in place. Don’t worry about finding potential customers, when you have the experts from Best Case Leads, to get the job done. We only provide the most recent lists of people who want to use your legal services without the hassle.

Explore More Articles

Why Law Firms Lose the Cases They Already Paid For: 6 Foundation Gaps We See From the Other Side

Marketing agencies write about law firm growth from the outside looking in. We have a different vantage point. Best Case Leads delivers exclusive personal injury leads to law firms across the country, which means we watch the same product, a real injured claimant...

Bicycle Crash Claims: What Personal Injury Firms Need to Know About Liability, Evidence, and Intake

In 2024, 1,103 cyclists were killed and an estimated 52,887 were injured in U.S. traffic crashes, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. For plaintiff firms, those crashes produce some of the most serious injuries in the motor vehicle docket...

The Jealous Mistress Was Always a Bad Business Model: A Growth Framework for Solo and Small Personal Injury Firms

The Jealous Mistress Was Always a Bad Business Model: A Growth Framework for Solo and Small Personal Injury Firms Justice Story's line about the law demanding "lavish homage" has been quoted to every law student for two centuries. It produced a profession with...

Nearly Half of Law Firms Cannot Be Reached by Phone. The Problem Is Not Marketing. It Is the Empty Chair Next to the Owner.

In 2024, Clio commissioned a secret-shopper study of American law firms. Researchers posed as prospective clients and contacted 500 firms by phone and email. The results, published in the 2024 Legal Trends Report, were unambiguous. Only 40 percent of firms answered...

The Trial Lawyer Who Never Tries a Case: How to Grow a Personal Injury Firm Without Losing the Only Leverage That Matters

In 1990, federal district courts completed 4,765 civil jury trials. In 2025, according to the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, they completed 1,048, a decline of 10 percent in a single year and roughly 78 percent over the generation. The state courts, where...

Best Case Leads Celebrates Sixth Consecutive Year on Inc. 5000 List of Fastest-Growing Private Companies in America

Aug 19, 2025 | Press Releases Houston, TX, August 18, 2025 — Best Case Leads, a pioneering leader in legal lead generation, proudly announces its sixth consecutive recognition on the prestigious Inc. 5000 fastest-growing private companies in America, securing...

Baby Formula Litigation, NEC Claims, and the Evolving Landscape of Mass Torts

By Fadi Agour, J.D. Families of premature infants who developed necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC) after being fed cow–milk–based formula products like Similac and Enfamil continue to pursue justice in both state and federal courts. Recent...

Mass Tort Landscape 2025: Key Cases, Trends & Strategic Opportunities

The mass tort landscape is evolving rapidly, with new cases gaining momentum and established litigations reaching critical phases. For law firms and legal marketers, timing is everything—success hinges on anticipating trends, securing high-value claimants early, and...

Zyprexa & Risperdal 2: The Breast Cancer Link That Could Ignite the Next Mass Tort

The pharmaceutical litigation landscape has seen its share of blockbuster cases—from opioid multidistrict litigations to the ongoing Paraquat Parkinson’s claims. But a new California lawsuit (Brown v. Johnson & Johnson et al.) could revive two legacy antipsychotics...

Mass Torts in 2025: A Legal Landscape in Flux

As 2025 unfolds, the world of mass tort litigation shows no signs of slowing down. From pharmaceutical giants to tech behemoths, corporations across industries are facing an unprecedented wave of lawsuits that could reshape their futures. With judges issuing critical...